Who is responsible?

Uncategorized
While perhaps underappreciated, vaccines are perhaps the greatest advance in modern medicine. Diseases that killed thousands and devastated millions of lives are simply prevented. It's not perfect - no science is - but from a historical perspective, the change is beyond dramatic. And it seems that we have become victims of our own success. It's hard to imagine that during the worldwide influenza epidemic of 1917 that anybody would argue against vaccinations. It's just as hard to imagine parents of a child with polio refusing to vaccinate their other children when it became available on principled grounds. The argument that "it's not necessary to vaccinate since these diseases don't really exist anymore" is actually quite common. The fallacy is that most people don't know anybody with these diseases is precisely…
Read More

Bioethics Roundup – July 18

Uncategorized
Why Spain has more organ donors than any other country in the world In the US, the default assumption is that a person does not consent to organ donation upon their death unless they specifically "opt-in." Spain has implemented an "opt-out" policy, arguing that many people would in theory be willing to donate, but for some reason or another, don't get around to opting-in. This gets around this problem. Given the US hyper focus on individual liberty, it doesn't seem that it would fly on these shores. Personhood and the Three Branches of Government "In the majority opinion of Roe vs. Wade, Justice Harry Blackmun wrote that if the notion of fetal personhood were established, the arguments for women's choice would collapse, "for the fetus' right to life would then…
Read More

Brain Death and the Controversial Case of Jahi McMath

Uncategorized
Last Thursday, Jahi McMath's family publicized that Jahi has died (been issued a death certificate in New Jersey). Jahi has been at the heart of the brain death debate in this country for the last 4 years, having been issued a death certificate in California in 2013 and now a death certificate in New Jersey in 2018. Her case has been the focus of much of bioethics for the past few years and likely will continue to occupy a great deal of thought for the foreseeable future. First part of the recent Harvard Medical School Conference on Brain Death: [embed]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tHD0OUUfiR0&feature=youtu.be[/embed]
Read More

Bioethics Roundup

Uncategorized
Nurse admits she overmedicated hospice patients to death – but no murder charges filed When hospice compensation decreases with each day that a patient stays in hospice, are we perhaps forgetting what hospice is really meant to do for patients? How to Provide Better Incentives to Organ Donors: Three experts discuss strategies to address the shortage of organs available for people who need transplants With a general distaste and opposition to monetary compensation for live organ donation (despite prospective studies showing its potential overall benefit), a search for creative solutions to save lives. My favorite incentive is for governmental provided lifetime health insurance matching that of the US representative in the donor's district. More on the benefits of that approach another time. Texas can't let misguided vaccination fears endanger all…
Read More